The Beatles Anthology
by Bob Smeaton, Geoff Wonfor, Kevin Godley

List Price: $79.98
Our Price: $53.54
You Save: $26.44 (33%)
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Buy Used: from $39.99 (click here)
Category: DVD
See more DVD details

DVD details

• Condition: New
• Format: DVD
• Box set; Black & White; Color; Dolby; DTS Surround Sound; DVD; NTSC

DVD Reviews of The Beatles Anthology

DVD Review: It's All Too Much
Summary: 5 Stars

Change is never easy and society occasionally elects gurus to help with that burden. The Beatles were pushed into that role sometimes willingly but just as often not. As a long time fan of the band, I found Anthology engrossing and fun to watch. When I purchased the videotapes I found I didn't return to them very often. This kind of surprised me but I discovered that I didn't have much desire to watch them twice much less three or four times. Perhaps it's the media overkill society we live in. More than likely, it's simply the fact that I appreciate the history but the music means much more to me. What I occasionally will do is dip my foot in one part or another of the Anthology, swim for a couple of laps and then I return to the music refreshed.

The inclusion of footage of the "Threatles" (as critics referred to them as a result of the Free As A Bird and Real Love sessions)jamming makes this collection much more essential than the previous version. It's a chance to see Paul, George and Ringo perform together for the first time since the break up of the band. A note of caution, however, is that these are exactly that--jamming with two yukes and percussion courtesy of Ringo's hands & pants. They aren't finished songs nor were they ever. It's still kind of cool is hear Paul occasionally perform with his acoustic (or electric) on a given tune to illustrate a point.

Given Harrison's recent death, there's a sense of closure now that this footage has been released. These are just three guys playing songs they love because they want to not because they're trying to recapture the past. Likewise, the video footage on the making of Free As A Bird and Real Love. Both songs neither hurt nor hinder the Beatles legacy but give long time fans what they've been clamoring for all these years--a reunion of sorts where John, Paul, George and Ringo "perform" together.

The inclusion of the footage from the recording sessions for Real Love and Free are also quite interesting. It provides a glimpse into the altered dynamic of the band. Without Lennon, they weren't quite The Beatles even with his ghostly voice haunting the studio monitors. In many respects, Paul, George and Ringo were paying tribute to a fallen comrad. All of that perspective was lost due to the media saturation and expectations when Anthology came out. Each member of the band had carved out a life and career and still managed to come to terms with a rewarding but difficult past. The bitterness of the divorce was more of a distant memory and the surviving trio was just trying to recapture that feeling of fun they had before they became an industry.

Jeff Lynne faced much criticism at the time for his production of the two "new" Beatles songs. In fact, his sympathetic production ushers the material into the 90's without losing the very qualities that made the band's music so special. While the songs themselves aren't the best Lennon ever wrote (in fact Lennon, McCartney and Harrison wrote much better material during their often uneven solo careers), it's not the quality of the song that matters: what matters is the feeling brought to the performance of the tunes. It's not groundbreaking nor was it meant to be and it shows The Beatles as they really were--a really good band that made it very very big (to paraphrase John).The insights into the making of the Free video are particularly interesting. Director Joe Pykta discusses the origin of the concept, various additions, subtractions made to the video. It's a loving valentine to the band with witty references to oodles of Beatles songs.

The impact of the band on popular music is put into perspective by Ringo when he commented that there were lots of big acts and very few monster acts (to paraphrase him). They were the monsters of rock music at a time when there was a lot of popularity for a lot of bands. It all came down to their level of success and their cultural impact as a result.

The sound quality is terrific and although the remix to 5.1 will continue to generate debate amongst Beatles fans. Tampering with the past is touchy business much less a fan's memory of "how it was". Luckily, The Beatles themselves recognized that they were some mythical Holy Grail nor are they some sort of ancient artifact. The remix breathes new life into the older material allowing a new generation to appreciate how groundbreaking much of what the band accomplished really was.

While there's a lot of essential material here, the Anthology really could have been edited down to a two or even three disc set. There is considerable repetition. That was necessarily, no doubt, because each member had not only their own recollections to share but their own agenda about the past as well.

Nevertheless, the wealth of material is worthwhile having for hardcore Beatles fans and rock historians. Is it essential? Well that all depends on how important the era was to you and whether you feel the need to relive it again. As I said sometimes a short dip in the pool of memory refreshes both the soul and makes us appreciate the importance of what is past.

The DVD is less awkward than the videos and more user friendly than both the laserdisc & videotape formats. The importance of the Anthology for fans goes beyond the music or any need to recapture the past. It's comfort video for the soul. Anthology manages to digest an important era in history with a fair perspective. The Beatles themselves recognized they weren't the pied-pipers of the era. They were just for guys making music they thought was important and trying to live down a reputation that was hoisted upon them by the media and a adoring world. Anthology is like an old coat you keep around because it's smells and touch bring life to distant memories.

Now for the nasty stuff--criticism. The picture verges from fair to excellent. The earlier interviews of Paul, George & Ringo look like they were shot without either adequate lighting or on early digital video. The quality doesn't hold up to some of the other footage. The inclusion of the band's promotional videos and performances are great--but it would have been nice to have an option to play them without commentary or as supplements on the 5th disc. No doubt, Capitol plans on re-releasing the Red and Blue albums on DVD with the assorted collection of promo videos included (and there were quite a few).

Anthology is a link to the past not buried by the past. Enjoy Beatles fans, at least some of the band's music has jumped into the DVD age.

Description of The Beatles Anthology

Classic Rock Music CDs

• Music > Styles
• Rock