 |
Man of La Mancha by Arthur Hiller
Buy this DVD movie at online store in your country
Canada
DVD detailsActor: Harry Andrews, James Coco, John Castle (II), Peter O'Toole, Sophia Loren Director: Arthur Hiller Brand: TWENTIETH CENTURY FOX HOME ENT DVD: Region Code 1 Audio: English (Original Language), Dolby Digital 5.1; Spanish (Original Language), Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround; English (Subtitled); Spanish (Subtitled); French (Subtitled); Spanish (Dubbed), Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround Format: AC-3, Anamorphic, Color, Dolby, Dubbed, DVD-Video, NTSC, Subtitled Picture Format: 1.85:1 Running Time: 129 minutes DVD Release Date: 2004-05-11 Audience Rating: PG (Parental Guidance Suggested) Studio: MGM (Video & DVD)
DVD Reviews of Man of La ManchaDVD Review: Proves The Point Cervantes Was Trying To Make Summary: 2 StarsThis movie is a contradiction of what Cervantes intended. The very ideals to which the musicial aspires are exactly that which the author of Don Quixote was making fun of.
The plot is taken out of context. The fine acting, direction, et cetera with the music and songs not withstanding, it is an inane presentation of the story. Don Miguel was never in trouble with Church authorities who treasured his writings - which were actually two books. He was imprisoned for alleged misappropriation of funds when he was something of a courier for the Spanish treasury. In prison he wrote some but not all of Don Quixote. The author was a slave and a prisoner as Peter O'Toole says in the movie, captured by the infidels and held for ransom. He was a soldier maimed in the battle of Lepanto near Cornith.
As noted by another reviewer, Aldonza-Dulcinea is not a real character in the book, but exist only in the mind of Don Quixote who is so humored by Sancho. In the book, Sancho is sent by the Don with a message to Dulcinea. He returns, alleging that he delivered the message, knowing full well Dulcinea does not exist. Later in their travels Don Quixote is eager for Sancho to take him to Dulcinea. In a pickle, Sancho riding with the Don sees two women, one of whom is Aldonza, who Sancho insist is Dulcinea but bewitched by the Great Enchanter to look like Aldonza. The event is full of humor at Don Quixote's constertation, the two hapless women's confusion, and Sancho secretely laughing to himself at the whole affair.
Also, it was the Knight of the Moon, and not the Knight of the Mirrors who defeated Don Quixote. Both were Sanson Carrasco in disguise, who as the Knight of the Mirrors is caught off guard in a joust and knocked off his horse by the Don. This was clearly shown in the horrible Hallmark hall of shame television movie with John Lithgow as Don Quixote.
If the reader of this review wants the truth of Don Quixote and Don Miguel, as with all great works, ditch the movies and read the books!
DVD Review: fast shipper !!! Summary: 5 StarsI am very happy with the DVD I bought. Good shape , fast shipping.. overalll good experence..
DVD Review: A Great Film! Summary: 5 StarsThere are always going to be people who say that the movie isn't as good as the book, or the stage version, or is historically inaccurate. We can gripe about these things or we can take the film as it is and enjoy it. I prefer the latter. Actually this is the theme of the story---to see beauty in life or to see ugliness, naming that "reality."
Perhaps I was lucky not to have seen the original stage performance so I wasn't disappointed. But I agree with the Amazon reviewer that it's hard to imagine anyone better suited to play the role than Peter O'Toole. O'Toole, better than almost any actor I know, can walk the fine line between madness and sanity without losing his balance. He brings his own unique qualities of dignity, humour, craziness and beauty to this role. I would much, much prefer to see such a performance than that of someone who had a "better" singing voice. I loved the way he stood, stick-straight, with no dramatic gestures while singing The Impossible Dream. Just his posture and regal bearing brought a poignant quality that the best operatic tenor wouldn't have done. (Some folks here are complaining that he was miscast due to his lack of singing ability while others are complaining that his singing voice was dubbed and they didn't like that singer, either...)
I did find the acting of Sophia Loren a little wooden but she looks great and that seems important. James Coco is adorably rotund and earthy as Sancho Panza. The rest of the cast does a good job, too.
I was surprised that the film was made so long ago. It is one that certainly bears the passage of time. Cynics may want to pass on it but anyone with an open heart will love it.
DVD Review: Just bad casting maybe? Summary: 3 StarsThe Hollywood star system fails badly here: after all it is a musical and Sophia Loren and Peter O'Toole just can't sing a note for all their acting ability.
I would also fault the costumers from making the staging less than it should be, so that the misery is intensified in a less than poetic way?
There is no doubt that the play will survive this bad performance,
but I think that it deserved more. I'm sure it has seen better stage production before and after.
Still some of the beauty and pathos still came through...
DVD Review: Excellent movie, very enjoyable. Summary: 5 StarsI love the storyline, the acting, and all. It is a wonderful movie for people of all ages.
Description of Man of La ManchaAcademy Award?(r) winners* Peter O'toole and Sophia Loren are magnificent in this lavishlyproduced (LA Herald-Examiner) and beautifully acted (The New York Times) epic masterpiece. Featuring an Oscar?(r)-nominated** score with the classic 'the Impossible Dream, this original and daring (Films & Filming) musical is an experience not to be missed! Jailed during the Spanish Inquisition for offending the church, author Miguel de Cervantes (O'toole) is forced to act out one of his manuscripts for the entertainment of fellow inmates. Cervantes delivers a rapturous performance as the legendary Don Quixote, the chivalrous knight whose choice to see lifeas it should be, not as it is, takes him into battles with an imaginary foe and into romance with the beautiful Dulcinea (Loren). *O'toole: Honorary Award (2002); Loren: Actress, Two Women (1961), Honorary Award (1990) **1972 It's hard to imagine a finer Don Quixote than Peter O'Toole, who's spent most of his career with a slightly mad, dreaming look in his marvelous eyes. O'Toole's suitability for the role is tested by the Broadway treatment of Man of La Mancha, the film version of the hit stage musical. Everybody knows "The Impossible Dream," that indomitable hymn to, well, quixotic questing, and it is indeed the best of the Spanish-inflected songs. Despite the location shooting in Italy, Love Story director Arthur Hiller can't elude the stagey concept (in which Cervantes, imprisoned by the Inquisition, acts out the tale of Don Quixote for his fellow prisoners). James Coco, as Sancho Panza, is overshadowed by the film's irresistible Dulcinea: Sophia Loren, at her mature peak. (Her singing, alas, is not as ripe as her beautiful self.) If you love Cervantes for his earthy ironies, this movie will seem a curious slice of inspirational shtick. --Robert Horton
|
 |